Florida may be famous for its beaches and nightlife, but locals know there’s another reason to explore the Sunshine State — exceptional steakhouses hiding in plain sight.
From old-school diners and family-owned spots to Brazilian churrascarias and wood-fired grills, these unassuming Florida restaurants consistently serve some of the best steaks in Florida, according to the people who eat there most.
If you’re searching for hidden gem steakhouses in Florida, this list is for you.
1. Chima Steakhouse (Orlando)
Brazilian Steakhouse with Endless Cuts
Chima Steakhouse delivers a vibrant Brazilian churrascaria experience where gauchos serve flame-grilled meats tableside. The nonstop service allows diners to sample multiple cuts, each seasoned to highlight natural beef flavors.
The atmosphere feels festive yet upscale, making it popular for celebrations and group dining.
Must-Try:
- Picanha (Brazilian top sirloin)
- Garlic sirloin
- Grilled lamb chops
Best For:
- Special occasions
- Group dinners
- Meat lovers who want variety
2. Andre’s Steak House (Naples)
Classic Old-School Steakhouse
Andre’s Steak House is a true throwback that locals cherish for its consistency. The menu stays focused on traditional steakhouse cuts prepared with time-tested methods.
The relaxed, nostalgic atmosphere keeps the focus where it belongs — on the steak.
Must-Try:
- Filet mignon
- Prime rib (when available)
Best For:
- Traditional steak lovers
- Quiet dinners
- Nostalgic dining experiences
3. Peter’s Steak House (Jensen Beach)
Laid-Back Steakhouse with Coastal Vibes
Peter’s Steak House offers a casual setting with surprisingly high-quality steaks. Locals love the welcoming service and dependable cooking that keeps them coming back.
It’s the kind of place where steak dinners feel relaxed, not rushed.
Must-Try:
- Ribeye steak
- New York strip
Best For:
- Casual dining
- Beach-day dinners
- Locals who value consistency
4. The Back Room Steakhouse (Apopka)
Hidden Steakhouse with Intimate Ambiance
The Back Room Steakhouse is known for its cozy, speakeasy-like atmosphere. The dim lighting and attentive service create a private dining experience that feels special every time.
Steaks are seasoned carefully and grilled to bring out their natural richness.
Must-Try:
- New York strip
- Center-cut filet
Best For:
- Date nights
- Anniversaries
- Quiet, intimate dinners
5. Saltgrass Steak House (Orlando)
Texas-Style Steakhouse Favorite
Saltgrass Steak House brings bold Texas flavors to Florida with flame-grilled steaks and hearty portions. Locals appreciate the balance between quality and affordability.
The relaxed atmosphere makes it an easy choice for everyday steak cravings.
Must-Try:
- Signature-seasoned sirloin
- Ribeye steak
Best For:
- Big appetites
- Casual group meals
- Value-focused diners
6. Cattle Ranch (Sanford)
Family-Owned Steakhouse with Huge Portions
Cattle Ranch keeps things simple — large cuts, honest prices, and friendly service. Locals love the unpretentious environment and generous servings.
The steaks are hearty and filling, perfect for classic steakhouse fans.
Must-Try:
- T-bone steak
- Ribeye
Best For:
- Families
- Large portions on a budget
- Classic steakhouse experience
7. Old Hickory Steakhouse (Kissimmee)
Upscale Steakhouse with Rustic Elegance
Old Hickory Steakhouse combines refined service with a warm, rustic interior. Known for aged steaks, it’s a popular choice for locals celebrating milestones.
Every detail, from presentation to service, feels polished.
Must-Try:
- Bone-in ribeye
- Dry-aged New York strip
Best For:
- Special occasions
- Romantic dinners
- Upscale steakhouse experiences
8. Embers Wood Grill (Gainesville)
Wood-Fired Steakhouse Hidden in Plain Sight
Embers Wood Grill surprises first-time visitors with its upscale interior and chef-driven menu. Steaks are cooked over real wood embers, adding depth and smokiness.
It’s considered one of Gainesville’s best dining spots by locals.
Must-Try:
- Wood-fired filet mignon
- Prime rib
Best For:
- Food enthusiasts
- Wood-grilled steak lovers
- Date nights
9. Salento Steakhouse (Jacksonville)
Colombian-Inspired Steakhouse
Salento Steakhouse blends traditional steakhouse fare with Colombian flavors, creating a unique and comforting dining experience.
The warm, inviting decor and friendly service make it a local favorite.
Must-Try:
- Colombian churrasco
- Skirt steak
Best For:
- Trying something different
- Cultural food experiences
- Family dinners
10. Okeechobee Steakhouse (West Palm Beach)
Florida’s Oldest Steakhouse
Okeechobee Steakhouse is a landmark known for its dry-aged beef and classic steakhouse service. Generations of locals trust it for consistently outstanding steaks.
The experience feels timeless, from the decor to the menu.
Must-Try:
- Dry-aged porterhouse
- Bone-in ribeye
Best For:
- Traditional steakhouse fans
- Celebrations
- Steak purists
Final Thoughts
These unassuming Florida steakhouses prove that the best steaks aren’t always in flashy locations. Locals keep these spots busy because they deliver quality, flavor, and consistency every time.
If you’re searching for the best steak in Florida, start here.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is the best steakhouse in Florida according to locals?
Many locals consider Okeechobee Steakhouse, Embers Wood Grill, and Andre’s Steak House among the best due to consistency, quality beef, and long-standing reputations.
Are these restaurants tourist-friendly?
Yes, but they’re locally loved, meaning they prioritize quality over flashy marketing.
Which Florida steakhouse is best for special occasions?
Chima Steakhouse, Old Hickory Steakhouse, and Okeechobee Steakhouse are ideal for celebrations.
Are there affordable steakhouse options in Florida?
Yes — Cattle Ranch and Peter’s Steak House are great value spots with generous portions.
Do these steakhouses offer non-steak options?
Most offer seafood, chicken, and sides, but steaks are the main highlight.